CMU School of Drama


Friday, October 02, 2026

If Subscriptions Are Dying, Are We the Ones Killing Them?

AMERICAN THEATRE: Ask 10 theatre leaders whether subscriptions are dying and you’ll get 10 defensible answers. Some organizations have watched their base erode for a decade. Others will tell you, accurately, that their numbers have held steady or grown, and that the eulogies say more about which institutions get written about than about the field as a whole. All things are true at once, which is exactly the problem: It means that the health of any one organization’s subscription program tells you almost nothing about the health of subscriptions as a category.

3 comments:

I.Brooke said...

Every theatre I have worked in, has had a big mission when it came to their subscriptions base. Enough that I was acutely aware of how it was doing, even existing far away from marketing in the scenic department. I have understood, to this point, that the subscription base is as vital as it is because it's a relatively stable/reliable source of ticket sales or revenue. It exists because people have enough faith in the theatre's brand or reputation to buy tickets before the season is necessarily published or reviewed. It spreads out interest between the shows, and guarantees some ticket sales even for the most underperforming show of the season. I think the article makes a really interesting point about all this. It impresses upon the importance of customers renewing their full season subscriptions, and that if given an easier more flexible option right next to a full season renewal option, people are going to go with the smaller one. However, the article also says, “None of this is an argument against the middle option—it’s an argument for using it on purpose.” I think this was a really great way of summarizing the point of the article which was not that the flexible option needs to be done away with, as it could be the difference between someone renewing on a limited basis, and someone walking completely away. It argues instead that the first option presented should not be the smaller ask, if theatres want people to commit to their full seasons.

Anton Popowitz said...

This article completely changes my perspective on the narrative that subscriptions are dying. The argument of Nave is that many cases of decline are not due to audience taste but to theater unintentionally pushing people in the wrong direction. The one that really got to me was the renewal letter. Of course, when someone puts a discount flex package next to the full season renewal, the person will opt for a smaller price. This is not a change of tastes but a natural thing people do. Downgrading looks acceptable while canceling does not. It is also true that the data cannot tell whether there is a difference in the reasons, and the organizations simply "prove" whatever they believe. I thought of this in connection to the new season of Confluence. They offer flex options along with the full season package, and it would be interesting to see the timing of these two things. The only problem is that this is a sponsored article of a consultant, a kind of advertisement. However, the audit questions at the end look very relevant and important to ask.

Haley Baynard said...

This is actually a really interesting interpretation of why subscriptions are going that I haven’t heard before. My parents have a subscription to our local theater back home and I know their reasoning is because it forces them to go out a see theater, because otherwise the ticket gets wasted. This summer I also worked in the Box Office where subscriptions were getting constantly renewed for CMU. Part of the reason that folks unsubscribed was mainly because we couldn’t get in contact with them to finalize the paperwork or they didn’t want to commit to so many shows. So I totally agree with this study that the easier option is what most people will choose. I am curious if this is more common in a certain age range or even level of theater, like what spaces was this study conducted in. Are subscriptions also more common in certain areas of the country compared to others?