CMU School of Drama


Monday, October 26, 2026

Make It or Send It Out?

Sign Builder Illustrated, The How-To Sign Industry Magazine: For many sign and graphics shop owners, there’s a certain satisfaction that comes with producing a job entirely in-house. From the initial design to the final installation, having control over every step of the process can make it easier to maintain quality, meet deadlines and keep customers happy. However, just because your shop has the equipment and expertise to complete a project doesn’t necessarily mean producing it yourself is always the smartest business decision.

3 comments:

Caitlyn W said...

When it comes to choosing whether to make something or sending it out the way businesses do. I think that experience is really similar to the tug of war struggle designers face. So many designers have a vision for how a show is supposed to look and more often than not designers are very protective of those artistic visions and feel a maternal ownership to them. As a designer in high school I designed and built my sets, it feels weird to me to design something and then let it go. There is this subconscious lack of trust when it comes to anyone handling my artistic vision that is not me. But in a larger theatre world you do not get to hold on to design every minute of the day, you have to let it go to the shops and fellow designers. Having trust in people we do not know very well to build or create the things we design can be a very difficult process.

Gabriel Nickerson said...

This is a very insightful article beyond just the sign making industry, and can honestly be applied to a huge number of things, from high school robotics to many branches of industrial manufacturing, to, of course, theater, which encompasses many of those sectors. I think this most applies to theater scene shops, and particularly automation, advanced rigging, and pyrotechnics, to name a few. Looking at scene shops, particularly small ones, maybe tied to an individual community theater, it almost certainly makes sense to contract out or bring in experts and companies for more advanced equipment, such as stage automation and people flying, because at least for places where employees are paid by the hour, because between equipment and increased labor, it will probably cost more. However, theater does have some somewhat unique restrictions. For one thing, many community theaters are very cost conscious, so they may end up doing it an alternate way (safely or less safely) instead of the professional way; additionally, in more complex union houses, union regulations may dictate who must do what, no matter the practical costs and realities. Also, depending on what you are outsourcing, some companies may not have an understanding of the urgency of theater (Kevin's story about molding). Overall, it is definitely advantageous to always keep outsourcing a mental option when planning.

Richard Manne said...

The “Make It or Send It Out?” dilemma overlaps greatly in the theatrical design world. As you go from middle and high school theatre, to college, and out into the professional world, your role is more and more specified. A scenic designer no longer is building their own sets, and the lighting designer doesn’t repair fixtures. These jobs are split amongst people who are better at it because that is what they have chosen to do. Similarly, in this sign shop example, outsourcing the task to someone else may be more effective and efficient for a number of factors. Expertise comes first to mind, but cost is not far behind. Another thing I noticed was brought up in the article is deciding which shop or factory to outsource to, and this directly applies to our world. Some shops may consistently deliver the service that you are dissatisfied with, and you need to recognize their negative impacts and find someone else. Implementing best business practices requires knowing your in-house capabilities, and outsourcing in order to stay efficient.