Did Critics Feel Nostalgic at The Fantasticks?

Broadway.com Buzz: "The Fantasticks, the Little Musical That Wouldn't Die, is back in New York at the new Snapple Theatre Center. The classic love story, which originally ran from 1960 to 2002 at the Sullivan Street Playhouse, features Burke Moses as El Gallo and composer Tom Jones (billed as 'Thomas Bruce') as the Old Actor, a role he also played 46 years ago. Were critics moved by the nostalgia of the longest-running musical in history?"